top of page

Is It Cheaper To Outsource Or Keep The Work In-House?

2 days ago
7 min read

Updated: 20 hours ago

The director opens your £600 quote for the monthly report, turns to the colleague who wrote the last one and asks, “Could we just do it again?” She can. What neither of them has in front of them is the Thursday she spent chasing figures, or the Friday morning her manager gave up to check them.

A £600 quote beside a full weekly diary and the question “Who gets Friday back?”

In this illustrative example, the decision is whether to accept the quote before next month’s reporting deadline. If their team has the time and can deliver the same report, doing it in-house may cost less. If it pushes paid work or repeated overtime into someone else’s week, the answer can change. Your buyer needs to see whose time the fee would release and what they could actually do with it.

Find out why the buyer plans to do it themselves

Start with a quote you know you lost to DIY. A buyer who went quiet may have postponed the job or had trouble accepting the quote on their phone. Leave the reason open until they tell you. The Objection Mapping guide explains how to link a lost decision to something the buyer actually said.

Ask the person who did the work to walk you through the last finished report. Who supplied the figures? Who chased the late return? Who spotted the mismatch and opened the file again? A director may remember the finished document. The person who delivered it can show you the reminder messages, diary changes and second draft.

  • If there is money but no spare time, find out which work moved. An appointment they could have taken or a shift they paid someone to cover gives you something to compare with the fee.

  • If they want to keep control, ask which decision matters. They may happily hand over the chasing if their manager still approves what goes to the board.

  • If the offer is the obstacle, fix that first. A Friday delivery is too late for a Thursday meeting. If your price excludes corrections, say so. Test the acceptance route on a phone as well.

Compare the same finished job over the same period

For the £600 quote, agree what counts as finished: a checked report by Friday, including one round of corrections. Your team would collect three returns, chase missing figures, reconcile the figures and prepare the draft. The customer would supply the source data and give final approval. This split lets the buyer keep control of the numbers without owning every reminder.

The Cabinet Office Sourcing Playbook compares in-house, external and mixed delivery. It also separates the work of moving a service from the work of running it. A business buying a monthly report can borrow both questions. Which parts should stay inside, and what happens in month one?

Whose time changes?

In-house and after handover

Operations staff

8 hours to gather, chase and prepare. After handover, 1 hour to supply source data.

Approving manager

4 hours to check, correct and sign off. After handover, 1 hour to approve.

Whole team

12 hours in-house. After handover, 2 hours in an ordinary month, or 6 in month one including set-up.

Illustrative monthly report. The buyer’s team spends 12 hours in-house, 6 hours in the first month with the supplier and 2 hours in an ordinary month.

All figures are illustrative. With four extra hours for access, briefing and the first run, the £600 fee releases six hours in month one (£100 per hour released). Thereafter it releases ten (£60 per hour). Over three months that is £1,800 for 26 hours, about £69 per hour. These figures assume a flat fee, no separate set-up charge and the same workload each month.

Find the point where the £600 fee pays for itself

Look at the ten hours individually. Seven belong to operations and three belong to the manager. Ask the manager what is already waiting for those three hours. Ask operations which paid cover they could take off the rota. The two answers can be worth very different amounts.

Suppose the manager could use all three hours on confirmed customer work that leaves £90 an hour after its extra costs. That adds £270. If the seven operations hours would otherwise be quiet, the business still needs £330 to cover the fee. Multiplying every hour by the manager’s rate would give the director the wrong answer.

Now change just one fact. The operations team can use its seven hours to cover a shift for which the business would otherwise pay £360. If that booking can genuinely be cancelled without a charge, the ordinary month produces £630 of benefit against £600 of cost. The margin is £30. If cover was prepaid or the manager’s customer work falls through, run the numbers again. Give each hour one use.

This is the relevant cost principle explained by ACCA. A salary that stays the same does not become cash saved. The opportunity cost is the benefit of work the team would otherwise give up. A quieter Friday or a dependable deadline may still be worth paying for. Let the buyer say which outcome matters.

Choose a review from the person who used to do the job

At this point the director can check the arithmetic. The colleague beside them has a different question: will she still have to send those Thursday reminders? Your scope can promise to take them on. A customer who used to do the chasing can describe who sent the reminders after the handover, including what happened when somebody missed the cut-off.

Research into how business buyers use customer references examined eight purchases of knowledge-intensive services and technology. Buyers used experience from others to understand the offer, the supplier and how the problem could be solved. For this quote, the helpful similarity is that the customer used to own the work. They needn’t be in the same industry.

Read the whole account before you select it. Can you identify what the customer did before, what moved across and what stayed with them? A review about a beautifully presented report belongs with a sample report. One that describes the last late return belongs beside this fee. The Selective Proof guide goes into choosing between genuine reviews.

If that detail is missing, ask a former in-house customer, “When the figures arrived late last month, what did you have to do? How did that compare with the last time you handled the report yourself?” Let them describe any extra work, too. Keep their wording and qualifications intact and check permission for the intended placement. The example’s ten hours should never find their way into the review.

Put that review between the price and “Accept quote”

Give the director one section they can forward to their colleague. Put the monthly fee at the top, then two short lines explaining what each team does. Place the customer’s review immediately below those lines and above the acceptance button. Both readers can now see the promise and judge it against someone’s experience.

Illustrative £600 monthly quote. One approved customer review sits below the supplier and buyer responsibilities and directly above Accept quote.

Use your seven-day trial to put one approved handover review on one live quote or package page. The EndorseHQ Toolkit gives you a review library and lets you choose exactly which account appears in each widget.

  1. Bring in the original. Import the existing review using the Chrome or Firefox extension, add it manually or use a CSV. Keep the source with your permission record.

  2. File it by the decision. Group it under a category such as “Used to do it in-house”. Read the account through the eyes of the colleague who still has to approve the report.

  3. Build and check the placement. Choose the Singular widget and hand-pick that review. On a phone, read from the price down to the acceptance button. If the customer normally receives a PDF, include the permitted wording in the same position in the exported quote.

Did more suitable buyers accept the quote?

Before you change the page, record comparable quotes sent, quotes accepted within your usual decision window and buyers who explicitly chose DIY. Keep price, scope, source and follow-up alongside each quote. Count unanswered quotes in the total sent and leave their loss reason unknown. Give each quote the full decision window before comparing groups.

After the change, divide accepted quotes by comparable quotes sent. Keep the counts beside the percentages. If you changed the scope and added the review together, judge the combined change. EndorseHQ widget views and clicks show whether the placement attracted attention. Your sales records show who signed. Ask a new customer which detail helped the person approving the spend decide.

In-house vs outsourcing FAQs

When is it cheaper to keep work in-house?

Keeping work inside usually needs less additional cash when trained staff have spare time, already have the tools and can meet the deadline. Compare the same quality and frequency. A new hire, extra shift or licence that is needed only for DIY changes the calculation. Over a longer contract, revisit which costs you could actually avoid.

How do you calculate the break-even point for outsourcing?

Add the cash costs the buyer can avoid to the additional contribution they can realistically earn with the hours returned. Compare that total with the supplier fee, any set-up costs and extra spending the buyer will still incur. In the ordinary month above, £270 of contribution leaves £330 of the fee to cover. If nothing else changes, the purchase falls short on financial grounds.

How do you estimate the time when nobody tracks it?

Reconstruct one recent job with the people who did it. Use diary entries, sent messages, file versions and approvals to estimate active time. A two-day wait for a reply is elapsed time. A 20-minute meeting with three people uses one team hour. If a quiet month and a busy month point to different decisions, time the next cycle or compare the options over the full season.

Which work should you outsource and which should stay in-house?

Hand over work with a clear output, an owner and a standard you can check. Keep decisions that depend on your judgement, access or accountability. In the report example, the supplier can chase contributors and reconcile their returns while the buyer retains final approval. If approvals still take four hours, recalculate using four. A partial handover can be the better buy.

Does a review need to say how much time was saved?

No. A customer can answer the buyer’s doubt by explaining who chased a late return and what they still had to approve. Use a figure only if the customer can substantiate it and has agreed to that use. Keep the period and circumstances with the number so the next buyer can judge how closely it fits their own week.

 
 
bottom of page